Oh usually I am not a fan of bread pudding, it's just dense and bad, BUT COMNANDERS BREAD PUDDING SHOUKD NOT BE MISSED!!! Ask your server about the history of the restaurant, it use to be a brothel! We started with soup, one bowl of their famous turtle soup and a bowl of their shrimp bisque. Our captain, Jared, was so friendly and attentive, and Ti Martin and Chef Tory stopped by our table too, such a thrill! But you can't beat the good deal. IT'S LIT!+ Crisp Romaine Salad - pretty good black pepper dressing+ Smoked Redfish & White Shrimp Boulettes + Soups 1-1-1 - this is my dream appetizer - 3 different kinds of soup!! Review tags are currently only available for English language reviews. Best believe my boyfriend and I took advantage of this deal! Service and the setting is the reason to go there. Here it is.I usually try to write a review after having eaten at a restaurant at least twice to make sure things are consistent and I didn't just have one good or bad experience. We had the Strawberry Shortcake for desert. Some of the neighboring tables of several people did get a little rambunctious, but it was a Saturday night, and New Orleans, and we would likely have been as much were it not just the two of us. I can't wait to return!! I have never had that happen before.This place was HUGE. Appetizers. Ranked #54 of 1,887 Restaurants in New Orleans… Commanders PalaceOur servers Shawn and DeWayne were awesome!Had the Chef Tory's Classic Creole Luncheon which included:Commander's Turtle Soup whichIncluded Rich veal stock simmered slowly for 72 hours with minced snapping turtle, holy trinity and pressed hen's eggs and finished tableside with aged sherry Orange Peel and Spiced Sugarcane Painted Quail from Broken Arrow Ranch stuffed quail with fire roasted chili boudin, pickled pork choucroute, crystal pulp and sticky satsuma syrup.Creole Bread Pudding Souffle - "The Queen of Creole Desserts"Finished tableside with whiskey cream sauce Wild White Shrimp and Grits toasted garlic and lemon seared Gulf Shrimp with roasted peppers, sweet onions grilled kale over cheve stone ground grits with charred red peppers pai t and New Orleans style barbeque butterGriddle Seared Gulf Fish creole spiced and cast iron seared over pan roasted Covey Rise farm truck vegetables, pickled fennel salad and minted pea puree25 cent Martini is a main stay only served weekday during lunch. It's the kind of place where you put on your Sunday best and pair it with a chef's hat (just ask for one and they will provide). Amazing experience and food to die for.Huge shout out to Jarryd!!!! Not sure what their regular martini sizes are, but the $0.25 glass seemed a bit smaller than some of the drinks from other restaurant. Jennifer C. - Albion, ME 09/09/20 Commanders Palace Gumbo brings the taste of New Orleans home. I highly recommend this place! Went for their first post-Covid brunch service and it was flawless. Really enjoyed our dinner. They made sure our glasses were never empty and supplied us with ample information about the menu, the restaurants storied history and even pointed out the restaurant's owner, Miss Ella Brennan, to us.What about the food, you ask? While I don't remember that experience as being mind-blowing my second time there was quite memorable. First of all I have to say bravo to the staff! Our table had balloons for my husband's birthday. The drinks waiter accidentally began to put champagne we hadn't ordered on our table, and caught her mistake halfway. However the flavor wasn't that special. Sample Five Course Tasting Menu Each guest will receive all 5 courses - each entrée course is served separately. For desert, the Bread Pudding Soufflé relaxed the palette and wasn't overwhelming. And that's why I keep coming back.When the good Lord is ready to take me, y'all can scatter my ashes at Commander's Palace. It's revered as a classic building so it was neat to see in person. Dessert consisted of their famous bread pudding and a piece of strawberry shortcake. Now I can say I've had turtle!+ Shrimp and Tasso Henican - served with pickled okra and the most amazing five pepper jelly+ Shrimp & Grits - just wow. There is a reason Commander's is #1 in New Orleans and one of the top restaurants in the world. The restaurant is taking Covid 19 seriously (the whole city is actually pretty serious and safe about this). I visited Commander's Palace on a Friday afternoon for their lunch special. However when it was time for dessert, they brought everyone something. Commander’s Palace is famous for its turtle soup. The ambiance was calm and lights were dimmed, the staff was amazing, we were seated on the 2nd floor. It was three floors (I think). While most of us true foodies will keep going back to the same restaurant over and over again just for the food most others keep coming back because of the atmosphere. Heads up: From now on, other Yelpers will be able to see how you voted. (The NOLA.com/Times-Picayune archive) Turtle soup continues to be popular at most of the city's classic Creole restaurants such as Arnaud's, Commander's Palace… It's also very bitter. We received one of the best seats in the house, in my opinion, as we got to people watch throughout our meal. Commander's Palace: Turtle soup!! Food: Started out with the infamous Turtle Soup, which tasted like a really good chili. A recent lunch of turtlesoup, stuffed quail, pecan pie and their creole cheesecake produced pure bliss. A recent lunch of turtle soup, stuffed quail, pecan pie and their creole cheesecake produced pure bliss. Commander's Palace . One New Orleans restaurant, however, wants to make its dishes available nationwide. Is it okay to go there and just order soup or are there lunch minimums involved? Restaurants focus a lot of their attention on the atmosphere they present to their customers. Then as now I though that was pure magic.Now a little bit about the food. It's flawless. All were delicious and to die for! - See 9,644 traveller reviews, 3,449 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. The history of this famous restaurant offers a glimpse into New Orleans' ante-bellum past. Upon our entrance, we were greeted by 3 employees and were seated immediately. Commander's Palace, New Orleans. To be totally honest, I didn't love the turtle soup, but my girlfriend really enjoyed it and I did really enjoy the bisque. Turtle soup at Commander's Palace, Thursday, Dec. 8, 2016. They took our temperature before entering the establishment. Where do I start? Staff file photo by Ted Jackson Rouses plans to expand the program with more restaurants at other stores in the days ahead. I would recommend reservations and request to be seated upstairs if available. Once cleared, we walked in and was welcomed by everybody. Commander's Palace: Turtle soup!! Loved by locals and visitors alike, and recognized with James Beard awards for food and service and Wine Spectator's Grand Award. We're talking slap-your-mama-then-lick-the-plate-good.You must, and I mean must, make room for dessert. It's supposed to be a thing in NOLA. - See 9,628 traveler reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. No jazz at brunch (at least not indoors, it was raining on this particular day), but I'm sure it's coming, and the atmosphere is still festive and so welcoming. Zoom in to see updated info. Commander's has an excellent atmosphere. It was impeccable! The service is good but I'm skipping the lunch in the future. I think everyone was working as a team setting- there was our waitress who took our orders, someone who took our drink orders, and another server who gave us our food. And for our entrees we got the duck and the shrimp. Thank you for coming back, Commander's! I still remember my first time coming here and experiencing the ballet-like movements of the waiters swooping in unison with entrees delivered with perfect precious to everyone at the table at the exact same moment. We went to Commanders on Halloween night but didn't expect such a spooky experience. Have an open mind. I thought turtle soup sounded weird to me but after I tried it- it was not weird at all....never judge before you try. Everyone else at the table started with the turtle soup, which they raved about. The ambience inside the restaurant is absolutely wonderful and the service was by far the best that we experienced at any eatery in the city. Every guy I saw had a suit on and all the women were all glammed up. Website. New Orleans. The food was good, but what stood out for us was the service. You know, just because.Service has been and will always be perfection. Enjoy the Brennan family's brand of Southern hospitality. The Turtle soup is a treasure and the garlic bread is it’s own food group. The .25 cent martinis were meh. Soups & Stews. It was too sweet though. This was the best part of the meal even though I usually don't order dessert. InterContinental (IHG) Hotels in New Orleans, Marriott Autograph Collection Hotels in New Orleans, Preferred Hotels & Resorts in New Orleans, Warehouse/Central Business District Hotels, Arts District / Warehouse District Hotels, Hotels near Blaine Kern's Mardi Gras World, Hotels near LSU Health Sciences Center New Orleans, Hotels near Crescent City School of Gaming and Bartending - New Orleans, Hotels near Stevenson Academy of Hair Design, Hotels near Our Lady of Holy Cross College, American Restaurants for Families in New Orleans, Cajun & Creole Restaurants in New Orleans, Cajun Restaurants for Large Groups in New Orleans, French Restaurants with Private Dining in New Orleans, Restaurants for Group Dining in New Orleans, Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in New Orleans, Arts District / Warehouse District Restaurants, Asian Restaurants in Central Business District, Hot Dogs in Arts District / Warehouse District, Steakhouses for Special Occasions in French Quarter. Our waiter made us feel as if we had known him a long time, and he so encouraged us all to return and sit at his table. My DH got the pecan pie which is always amazing. Our waiter, Jared, and his two assistants were cheerful and friendly. My third visit was for my birthday in October 2015.The service is wonderful. None of the items, turtle soup, salad, duck was that good. One of the interesting things I noticed was that by themselves, the coffee and the bread pudding souffle were not that great. Thanks. My husband absolutely LOVED his beef dish. All of the friendly happy waitresses, waiters and cooks in their element, laughing and cooking near perfect dishes in total bliss! It was amazing. Doesn't seem worth it considering the food is just average. I felt that it was a bit bland as well. It was like something out of a Hollywood set.They sat each of us and our waiter was so professional and pleasant! As mentioned before, shorts are a non-starter (despite the fact it gets stupid hot outside for much of the year). Hands down the BEST restaurant in New Orleans!!!!! Oh, and fellas, jackets are required. Even when we were walking to our tables, the servers were welcoming us to the restaurant. This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC. They just have one band that circles around the restaurant. Commander’s Palace is a landmark in the garden district and a grande dame of New Orleans. Commander's Palace is nestled in the heart of the historic New Orleans Garden District, just steps from the St. Charles Avenue streetcar line. The building was a traditionally old one and managed to keep its historic image in tact. It was a festive touch. Decent martinis. Entrees rotate but two of their classics are perennial standouts: the pecan crusted redfish and the boudin-stuffed quail. I ordered the three course meal- soup/salad, entree, and desert. Overall, all the food was just average. We had such excellent service from Jon. I feel like the service and the atmosphere are the two qualities that pushes Commander's to the very top of the list of must eat restaurants in NOLA. Commander’s Palace is famous for its Creole cuisine — particularly the turtle soup — and has been home to chefs like Emril Lagasse and Paul Prudhomme. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Menu may not be up to date. Otherwise, the service was attentive, but unobtrusive. I have never had turtle soup since then-such a unique food. Now under the watchful eye of co-proprietors Ti Adelaide Martin and Lally Brennan, the Brennan family's dedication to perfection has never wavered. Both were just average. My entree was the Orange Peel & Spiced Sugarcane Painted Quail. We tested all three kinds..and they didn't skimp on the alcohol either. It isnt a Nola trip without a reservation at Commander's! Shop 500+ food shops in America. We are famous for it, but it can easily be made at home when you want a hearty soup to warm your bones. Dress code: My wife wore a nice "going out" dress and I wore dress slacks, a button-down, and a jacket with no tie. I tried their turtle soup and the gumbo. I felt so bad for the staff but everything kept going. 1403 Washington Ave, New Orleans, LA 70130-5798 (Garden District) +1 504-899-8221. Commander's Crisp Romaine Salad (Coolinary Encore), Wild Louisiana White Shrimp Curry (Coolinary Encore), Brown Butter Blondie Ice Cream (Coolinary Encore). I can honestly say that I was very impressed with Commander's Palace. I will just not being returning. Best Turtle Soup - Commander's Palace. The flavor of the bread pudding was especially delicious (and I'm not usually a fan of bread pudding).The bottom line is that this restaurant is a New Orleans staple that dishes out excellent food to go along with excellent service.Our meal, with one round of cocktails and two cappuccinos came out to $150 before tip, an absolute bargain if you ask me. We were seated upstairs and the view was breathtaking. I loved the esthetic of this place! This place is great! If I had to choose ONE place to eat in NOLA, it would have to, have to, HAVE TO be to Commander's Palace for lunch! Ah maybe next years... Entrance/Ambiance: The aesthetic of the building looks that of an 1800's circus, but fitting to stand out in the area nonetheless. Their gumbo and turtle soup is as good as any you will ever have. 9,648 reviews #31 of 1,351 Restaurants in New Orleans ££££ American Cajun & Creole Seafood. more. We were seated at a socially distanced tables on the third floor. We were not disappointed. We were trying to order and the came out and said some of the entrees were off the table because of no oven. I was eating at a fancy NYC restaurant a few days before going to New Orleans, and I asked the maitre'd for restaurant recommendations and he supplied me with a list of five restaurants, placing special emphasis on Commander's Palace. I could totally see myself living at this restaurant. The … Absorb all this place has to offer - try the turtle soup - it's amazing! We loved the garden room. Please speak with us about your needs for your event. So you may just hear 1 or 2 songs during your brunch. The atmosphere makes the dining experience an enjoyable place to spend time. For my entree, I had the stuffed quail and my husband had the beef dish (I can't recall the name). Submit corrections. Nothing to special. Commander's Turtle Soup. So not my fav. Cafe Adelaide & The Swizzle Stick Bar: Commander's Palace Turtle Soup without the Drive! After reading reviews and watching foodies on Youtube about this place, my boufriend and I decided to book a reservation for brunch on a Friday. We ordered bubbles and a carafe of OJ so we could temper our own mimosas. Started with turtle soup! Yep you read that roght 25 cents cocktail at a very fancy restaurant. The food was excellent and the Bread Pudding is wonderful. The place is very classy and I heard they do not let people in if youre in your denim so dress accordingly. United States ; Louisiana (LA) New Orleans ; New Orleans Restaurants ; Commander's Palace; Search. We took our group there for our farewell luncheon before we all depart for our homes back on the west coast. Husband and I always like to eat at a fancy restaurant when we travel, and this was on our (my) list since the beginning. A final footnote: those who observe Catholic eating strictures will be interested to know that turtle is considered a seafood by the Church. - Edited by Yasmin Fahr Adapted from “Commander’s Wild Side” by Chef Tory McPhail Service: Our service was top notch as we had a main server, and dedicated refreshment employees throughout our meal. Improve this listing. Commander's created the modern New Orleans fusion of classic creole and down home cajun flavors and is still the standard bearer. It’s made with “the mean snapping turtles that bite you.” Just something fun to watch, as it seems that there is one cushioned seat per table of 4 seats, as the staff will seat the female exclusively when leading parties to their seats. Upon entering the restaurant our group of 4 were greeted by everyone that we met from the valet attendant, the reception area and the waiters that we passed. I can't wait to come back and try more things. Share. Apparently they are also famous for their 25 cents cocktails. The Moran family not only made turtle soup there, but was famous for serving it from a large, upturned tortoise shell. Some people got a crab tossed salad with a great presentation of an actual crab shell. I'm excited to say I finally visited the Commanders Palace for an anniversary dinner! Our server and overall service was on point! He was hilarious and made our night special. At the end of 2019, Ti Martin looked at the numbers for Commander’s Palace. We went for lunch on a Monday for my husband's 40th birthday. Kicking off these Try Before You Die Dishes of New Orleans, James Beard Award winning chef Tory McPhail explains why the turtle soup au sherry at Commander's Palace … You can find more info on this reputable casino website . Below is a sample dinner menu. This was a highly rated restaurant, so I had to try it. Servers are very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Turtle Soup at Commander's Palace "I loved the esthetic of this place! Seriously. Also, if you ask they'll probably pull out the flambé cart and whip you up a bananas foster. The view from the outside doesn't do justice to how large the restaurant is inside, as I felt as if I was one one door from walking into Narnia trying to find the restroom. My husband had the seafood cakes, and I had the shrimp for entrees. Save. So savory and delicious. Map updates are paused. Unlike the clear, consomme-like turtle soup eaten in most other places (including almost everywhere in Europe), Creole turtle soup is thick and almost a stew. My mom and I really enjoyed the "old" atmosphere as well. This visit to Commander's reconfirmed its reputation...but YMMV. In the early 1880's, when Louisiana officially joined the nation, eager young Anglo-Saxons flocked to this promising territory to make their fortunes. Will order again. The famous Commander’s Palace will start shipping its food right to your door, no matter where you live. It's nothing special and they don't allow you to get special blue cheese stuffed olives with the $0.25 martini. Commander's Palace: Best Turtle Soup - See 9,631 traveler reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. My husband had the salad, which was also so good. The food, omg the food was absolutely amazing. Serves 6. I highly recommend everything we ordered! What a way to make you feel special. Commander's Palace: TURTLE SOUP!!! Well of course it was amazing. Now, I don't know how they could see down there because it was pitch black in the dining room except for a few candles. Posted on September 8, 2020 September 8, 2020. Commander’s Palace – New Orleans. I can NOT visit Nola without coming here. I really felt bad for the servers because when the lights finally came on about 30-40 minutes later, there were lots of empty tables. My husband had the soup for his appetizer, and I had the shrimp Tasso. So good! Who does not like .25 martinis. I did not mention this to them as they are a well oiled machines and move a lot of tables through this weekday lunch. The power went out before we got our first course-effin 2020! We stopped by the iconic New Orleans restaurant to see how they make turtle soup. My first time at Commander's was in 2011 with awesome Lindsay A. They have 4 different types of martinis for you to try. 3,446 photos. Own or manage this property? Still thinking about this restaurant years later. The staff and service is impeccable and the food is mouth watering. We even got a tour of the place - through the kitchen and everything. We have dined here for over 35 years. Combined, the coffee helped tone down the sweetness of the souffle and the coffee wasn't as bitter with the souffle. We ordered from the Coolinary lunch menu that day. The weekday lunch is a great way to go if you happen to be in New Orleans during the week. We left stuffed and happy! Commanders Palace suggests the list of the top ten online casino sites available for free on the web. For a main course we had the pecan crusted gulf fish as well as shrimp and grits. Commander's Palace: Turtle soup!! It seemed to be stuffed with Jambalaya, but I could not be sure. One thing I did look forward to was the jazz brunch of weekends. New Orleans-style turtle soup is as unique to our cuisine as gumbo. Both were excellent. The food was very good (the gumbo was meh), and the service was excellent. There is a new chef and I'm not quite sold on the menu but maybe it's a COVID adjustment they're dealing with. Because it was December, we were given jingle bells on a blue ribbon to wear. So for my 600th review I am going to finally finish up a review that has been sitting in my drafts for almost 5 years. See all restaurants in New Orleans. There is a reason Commander's is #1 in New Orleans and one of … The bread pudding souffle was really unique. The catfish I was serviced was presented nicely but tasted rancid. 1403 Washington Ave, New Orleans, LA 70130-5798 +1 504-899-8221 … It's very strong and unique. Honey had fish, I had duck, wow wow wow. Slightly spicy (a Cajun slow heat) full of savory flavor! United States ; Louisiana (LA) New Orleans ; New Orleans Restaurants ; Commander's Palace; Search “Best Turtle Soup” Review of Commander's Palace. It's the sort of place where your table's brunch balloons will be hung right next to a silver centerpiece. There weren't any apps just soups and salads. It was my friend Kim's Birthday so a live jazz band made their way to our table and played 5 classic New Orleans songs. You may feel uncomfortable in just polos and/or jeans. Commander's Palace: Best Turtle Soup Ever - See 9,628 traveler reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. Commander's Palace: Best Turtle Soup Ever - See 9,628 traveler reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. The gumbo had tiny overcooked shrimp and redfish?!! Ownership passed through several hands and each of them added their own special touches. In sum: Restaurants at that level all have similar quality food (with the exception of some signature dishes), it's the service that often distinguishes them. The experience lost something after that but it was no one's fault ( well, maybe the fault of a ghost from the cemetery across the street). The portion is huge! There is a dress code of business casual to business so this means, you can't wear tennis shoes or like exercising clothes.The manager will walk you through the kitchen where you will get to see all of the magic happen! Turtle soup has been on the Commander’s Palace menu since it opened in 1893 and is recognized as being the best and most authentic version in the United States. The experience before (albeit years ago) was pretty dismal. We had an early reservation at 6:00 hardly anyone was there and I was happy to see that they took temperatures at the door and had the tables blocked off and socially distanced. Legendary Seafood Gumbo from Commander's Palace shipped nationwide on Goldbelly. Commander's Palace. You are greeted my pleasant diverse staff upon arrival. Recipe courtesy of Commander's Palace. Also, most of the locals that I asked in New Orleans also recommended that we check it out and we are so happy that we did. This garlic bread has been a staple in our restaurant and is served warm at every table when you join us to dine. After a while they started telling us that less and less items weren't available. They have resumed in dining operations with impecable service and outstanding food. Garden District: 1403 Washington Ave. 504-899-8221. My husband had a crab salad that was on special it was so good. Over the years I have been here many times and Commander's never, ever lets me down. Commander's is BACK and as wonderful as ever!! So out of four times here three have been wonderful experiences. The food was just average. My second time was August 2015 for brunch. I thought that was an interesting observation. I would like to mention one waiter by the name of Billy that went out of his way to make sure that we were well taken care off. Want to chime in? The lighting, the seating, and the music are all perfectly balanced.I will state that I have been to Commander's only one time since 2015. Would recommend not on the rocks and the Commander's or Cosmopolitan. We asked them if we don't have to order so much food, but that's not very common. Very delicious. I'm a huge crust fan and was slightly disappointed how thin it was, but it didn't take away how good and fresh it was.I would reccomend everyone to make reservations and wear nice outfits. There's the creole cream cheesecake (with far more tang than anything from New York), Miss Ella's ice cream parfait with its sumptuous whipped cream and sticky praline sauce, or the dreamy bread pudding soufflé. They offer 2 course lunch sets and a classic Creole luncheon, but we decided to order a few of our server's recommendations a la carte. Similar food offerings. Our clients will never forget this and thanked us many times for the offering. My favorites are the turtle soup and the soufflé bread pudding. Vince also did a fantastic job always making sure our glasses were full and explaining his favorites on the menu Must haves: turtle soup, pecan crusted red fish, and the bread pudding souffléMake sure to walk around the garden district about an hour before your reservation. It's a magical land where a lowly, unimportant plebeian like me is made to feel like a king. I even went on a Wednesday. Turtle Soup A Commander's classic finished with a splash of sherry Café Pierre Lacquered Texas Quail Smoky Cajun boudin stuffed quail over a nest of tangy bacon braised cabbage with rustic roots, Crystal hot sauce pulp and sticky Grand Marnier & Cognac jus Creole Bread Pudding Soufflé "The Queen of Creole Desserts" ~ Finished tableside with warm whiskey cream sauce ^ Back to top. The building was a traditionally old one and managed to keep its historic image in tact. Mainly due to my crazy work schedule. One thing you have to try is NOLA's coffee. I have missed the turtle soup and that garlic bread, and my companions loved their salads. Add two loaves of Commander’s Palace’s legendary garlic bread. Commander's Turtle Soup at Commander's Palace "Commanders PalaceOur servers Shawn and DeWayne were awesome!Had the Chef Tory's Classic Creole Luncheon which included:Commander's Turtle Soup whichIncluded Rich veal stock simmered slowly for… Very apologetic, she later brought us complimentary shooters of their mango rum cocktail (that was delicious). - See 9,628 traveler reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. It was cooked at the right texture. My trio came with turtle soup, gumbo, and soft shell crab. Commander's Palace: My First Turtle Soup - See 9,628 traveller reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. Commander's Palace. ABOUT: The quintessential New Orleans dining experience. - See 731 traveler reviews, 198 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor. In short, dudes wear your church clothes, but not necessarily Easter or Christmas nice (though you wouldn't be out of place if you did). A Commander's classic finished with a splash of sherry. There is a dress code of… and a delicious souffle for dessert. So good. Both of the soups were a bit salty as well. I had the turtle soup that everyone was raving about and loved every bite! And if the food doesn't convince you, they offer 25 cent martinis. I ordered the famous turtle soup, but was not impressed, it tasted fine but was more like a vegetable soup with minced up meat so the turtle taste was not strong. Even a slight performance for our dessert to post on our respective social media pages. I ordered the a shrimp and grits dish but the goat cheese was so strong not my favorite. I forgot specifically what I ordered but I do remember their turtle soup! Claimed . Answer 1 of 21: Looking to do a food crawl in NO and want to try the turtle soup at Commanders Palace. Don't miss your dessert if you dine there! It was great! The only catch is that it all depends on where you sit for the jazz brunch. The turtle soup is the best in the city. We opted for the three course, great value! It's simply everything you hope and dream a restaurant can be. Reasonably priced for wonderful service! After having a rather "off" experience at Commander's a few years ago, my wife and I decided to give it another shot on our anniversary. For dessert, we had cheekcase to share. - See 9,628 traveller reviews, 3,428 candid photos, and great deals for New Orleans, LA, at Tripadvisor.